Updated date:

Homemade, Low-Sugar Pumpkin Muffin Recipe

Helena Ricketts loves cooking from scratch and sharing her recipes with anyone who wants to try something new in the world of food.

Pumpkin muffins just out of the oven and cooling on the rack.

Pumpkin muffins just out of the oven and cooling on the rack.

The Perfect Sugar Alternative: Honey

I've hunted for a great pumpkin muffin recipe for what seems like forever and kept running into the same problem every time I found one I thought I may like. I'd mix the batter up and anticipate the first bite of goodness from straight from the oven. They were all sugar candy sweet because there was always too much sugar in the recipe. Baking with a sugar substitute always seems to leave a synthetic after taste that I find extremely bitter and unpleasant. So what do you do when you can't find what tickles your taste buds? Develop it yourself so that's what I did. The best part about it? I was able to use local honey which I think makes it even better.

The Indiana honey that was used instead of the majority of the sugar in these muffins.

The Indiana honey that was used instead of the majority of the sugar in these muffins.

After some trial and error that usually ended up with a soupy, gloppy, tasteless mess, I found the right combination to make these little gems. They have just the right amount of spice but that can always be adjusted to your liking. They are moist and dense with a wonderful pumpkin and slight aftertaste of the honey that doesn't linger but does remind you of the beautiful thing you have just consumed. It's not a candy bar kinda sweet. The honey creates a sweet that your taste buds will recognize as a naturally sweet baked good.

Another great thing about this recipe is that there are three slight variations that you can try. For those of you who are fans of just the top portion of the muffins, I have instructions on how you can bake these in a great little silicone shallow muffin pan that will give you a crispy edge with minimal muffin bottom boredom. I love this method and if you don't have one of these pans but are a fan of the muffin caps, you should really get one. I didn't realize how much I actually do like just the tops until I started using a muffin top pan!

The other two variations are full-size muffins. One type I left plain and added some lovely plump raisins to the other just to mix it up a bit. I imagine that any type of dried fruit would be amazing in these. Banana, cranberries or dried apples come to mind immediately and will be an addition to the next batch of these muffins in my house.

These pumpkin muffins would be great iced with cream cheese icing but are just as yummy when you eat them plain. Nuke them in the microwave for a few seconds on the second day for a warm tasty breakfast that can be enjoyed with the morning coffee or a nice hot cup of tea.

Above all, enjoy!

I used organic pumpkin puree for these muffins but you can use canned pumpkin.  Just make sure it is NOT pumpkin pie filling!

I used organic pumpkin puree for these muffins but you can use canned pumpkin. Just make sure it is NOT pumpkin pie filling!

Cook Time

Prep timeCook timeReady inYields

30 min

20 min

50 min

Approximately 18 muffins

Ingredients

  • 1 1/2 cups flour
  • 1/3 cup sugar
  • 1/3 cup lightly packed brown sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
  • pinch ginger
  • 2 fresh eggs
  • 1 cup local honey
  • 1 cup pumpkin puree
  • 1 cup dried fruit like raisins, bananas, apples, optional

Instructions

  1. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Grease the pan you are using with butter and coat lightly with either flour or sugar.
  2. Mix all of the dry ingredients until well blended.
  3. In a separate bowl, mix all of the wet ingredients (eggs, honey, and pumpkin) until well blended.
  4. Add 1/4 of the wet ingredients to the dry and give it a few stirs to get it started. Add the next 1/4 of the wet ingredients to the dry and stir again. At this point, you can add the rest of the wet ingredients to the dry and mix until blended. If you are adding any dried fruit like raisins, now is the time to add that to the batter.
  5. Spoon into your pan, filling each muffin cup 2/3 of the way full. If you are using a shallow muffin pan, fill them just a tiny bit over 1/2 full for a regular rounded top or to go for the gusto, fill them the 2/3 way full and they will rise to spill out over the top of the pan for a larger crown and more crispy edge.
  6. Put the pan into your preheated oven. For regular size full muffins, you'll bake them for 20 to 25 minutes. For the shallow silicone muffin top lover pan, you'll bake for approximately 15 minutes. Adjust time as needed by testing with a toothpick. When the toothpick is inserted into the center, it will come out clean when the muffins are done.
  7. Allow them to cool for a few minutes inside the pan. Muffins cooked in silicone should pop right out. For full-size muffins cooked in a metal muffin pan, run a butter knife around the edges to make sure they are loose from the pan and either lift them out by hand or turn them out onto a cooling rack.
  8. Enjoy them while they are warm or allow them to cool if you are going to ice them.

What Did You Think?

Comments

Helena Ricketts (author) from Indiana on June 04, 2013:

Oh sorry! I hope they tasted ok though!

peachy from Home Sweet Home on June 04, 2013:

i love the look of your pumpkin muffins. I didn't know that i need to spread flour and butter in the muffin tins. No wonder my muffins got stuck! Thanks for sharing the muffin hub. Voted up

Thelma Alberts from Germany and Philippines on January 02, 2013:

It sounds yummy. I´ll try your recipe. I have not eaten pumpkin muffins yet in my life. Thanks for sharing. Happy New Year!

Helena Ricketts (author) from Indiana on January 01, 2013:

Thanks everyone! I hope you try them, they are really good. If you do, please let me know what you think of them! :)

Virginia Kearney from United States on January 01, 2013:

My kids love pumpkin muffins. I'd never thought of making them with honey. Great idea because that goes so nicely with the pumpkin taste. Terrific Hub!

Connie Smith from Southern Tier New York State on January 01, 2013:

Helena, this sounds so good! I know what you mean about the synthetic super sweetness that just ruins the dessert. I'm bookmarking this because I absolutely love pumpkin anything. And I try very hard to eat healthy as much as possible. Voted Up and Useful also Pinned

carol stanley from Arizona on January 01, 2013:

Thanks for writing this great pumpkin muffin without sugar. Great recipe..and I am also pinning.

Tammy Odom on December 31, 2012:

This sounds so good, I love honey but I love pumkin better. Its your choice, and if you like the pumkin taste or the honey taste. If you like pumkin add more to the recipe and keep your honey measurement. I'm going to make these. Yum Yum

Sueswan on December 31, 2012:

Hi Helena,

I am hooked on chocolate chip muffins from the local donut shop which I know are very high in fat and calories.

I look forward to trying these homemade pumpkin muffins.

Happy New Year

Deborah Brooks Langford from Brownsville,TX on December 31, 2012:

wow this sounds wonderful I love honey and this is my favorite kind of

muffins.. I am sharing on cooking time and pinning

Happy new year

Debbie