My name is Becki, and I am a wife, a mother, a daughter, a sister, and a friend.
Did You Know That Hot Chocolate and Hot Cocoa Aren't the Same Thing?
Many Americans don't. In fact, I was among them until quite recently. Growing up, my mother used to mix hot milk with Nestle Quick and call that "hot chocolate." In fact, this concoction is neither hot cocoa nor hot chocolate! I had no way of knowing better until I got informed, and then had my first opportunity to have some hot chocolate.
Most Americans refer to hot cocoa as hot chocolate. Even companies selling hot cocoa often call their powders hot chocolate. By their nature as powders, these commercial mixes cannot be called "hot chocolate."
If you've never experienced hot chocolate before, this article will explain the difference to you and help you through the process of making your own hot chocolate or tell you where you can get some of your own as a special treat.
Hot chocolate is often more expensive, but it's also very much worth the extra cost to purchase it!
What Do the Chains Sell: Hot Chocolate or Hot Cocoa?
Most chain shoppes advertise hot chocolate. Their product, however, is syrup-based. Real hot chocolate has a base of solid chocolate, often which has been melted down and re-formed or mixed with other ingredients in order to achieve a particular consistency which can be mixed with milk and cream (or half and half).
Starbucks, for example, provides a product made with vanilla and mocha-flavored syrups. This is, in essence, hot chocolate milk. That's what you're getting when you purchase hot chocolate from a retailer of this sort. Keep this in mind when ordering. It may taste amazing, but you'll get a different experience if you try real hot chocolate.
What Is Cocoa?
Cocoa, as it pertains to this article, is a powder that is a by-product of the process by which we create chocolate. This powder is often used to flavor baked goods and in this case, hot drinks. Combined with sugar, it makes a sweet substitute for rich milk or dark chocolate.
The word cocoa may also be used in relation to chocolate as a liquid extract from the cacao bean which is used in the creation of the resulting chocolate.
Chocolate starts as Cacao and becomes cocoa, which produces chocolate. Cocoa refers either to the liquid extracted from the beans or to the powder that is a by-product. The powder is used to provide a chocolate flavor to products but doesn't really taste like chocolate—it tastes like cocoa.
What Is Hot Chocolate?
Hot chocolate is just what it sounds like: It's chocolate that is hot. This chocolate is mixed with hot milk (or usually a mixture of milk and half and half or milk and cream) and is then served hot, or sometimes steamed as with a latte.
You can find many recipes for hot chocolate that differ from one another, but the main ingredients of any hot chocolate are chocolate (usually shaved chocolate but sometimes it's cubed as in the picture above), milk and cream. The chocolate may be thickened with ingredients such as corn starch in order to give it a creamier texture.
As with cocoa, hot chocolate is relatively easy to make at home in your kitchen if you have the right ingredients, but the quality will vary depending on the base chocolate that you're using. The higher quality your chocolate, the higher quality your drink, so use chocolate you really enjoy.
Hot Chocolate vs Hot Cocoa: Which Is Better?
It depends on what you like. If you're accustomed to coffee-type drinks, you may prefer hot cocoa because it still has a creamy consistency and it has a milder, more consistent flavor. Hot cocoa is, in general, hot cocoa. Some cocoas may be marketed as "dark chocolate" but most of those you can buy from the store are similar. Recipes, however, may vary.
Hot chocolate is richer, it's creamier and it tastes very much like you're drinking a chocolate bar.
The difference between the two is in the richness. Most Europeans wouldn't recognize what Americans call "hot chocolate" as chocolate at all and would likely turn their noses up at it. If you haven't tried hot chocolate, now is a very good time to give it a taste!
What to Add to Hot Cocoa or Hot Chocolate
- Cayenne pepper (ground)
- Cinnamon (ground)
- Peppermint flakes
- Vanilla extract
How to Add Flavor Hot Cocoa or Hot Chocolate
Both hot chocolate and hot cocoa can take extra flavors added to them, and the traditional additive may surprise you! Have you ever tried hot cocoa with cayenne pepper added to it?
The key to adding flavors to your cocoa or chocolate is to do it in the right amounts. If you're going to add ground cayenne pepper to your drink, make sure that you mix it in thoroughly as you're going to have a very spicy drink otherwise. Some cafes rim their cups with the powder and the flavor can be quite shocking. Purchasing one of these from a coffee house isn't recommended as you cannot prepare the drink to your own taste.
Chocolate can be flavored similarly as well. For some ideas for what you can add to your hot cocoa or hot chocolate, see the list to the right.
Make Hot Cocoa Mix at Home
No hot cocoa mix that you can make at home will ever compare to making your hot cocoa mix at home. You may be able to find several different recipes on the internet. Some are more complex than others (some are intended to be mixed with water while others are intended to be mixed with milk) and what you choose depends on you.
The recipe in the video below is uncomplicated and involves only three ingredients (including the milk). Note that the man in the video refers to this as "hot chocolate" but it is, in fact, cocoa.
The video above will show you how to make your own delicious hot chocolate at home. This should turn out amazing and rich, so different from the cocoa that you're accustomed to drinking. If you've never had hot chocolate, make sure that you remember that you're drinking a food! Leave some room for this beautiful dessert!
© 2014 Becki Rizzuti
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on October 28, 2018:
How do you figure this is an ad for Starbucks?
Dingbat3 on May 10, 2018:
Thanks, Jeff, for clearing that up. I might be getting close to 60 but I haven't lost all my marbles yet. I do not want the author to feel I'm picking on her because I'm not. I feel maybe there may have been a communication glitch? Although she didn't appear to comment in any way? Maybe in my 57 years of age I just didn't see a reply from her? Surely it's not bad manners!
Jeff on January 04, 2018:
While your recipes are fine, and your information about the practical differences of bar and powder chocolate are correct, your technical information about what chocolate is is completely wrong.
There are only two components in raw chocolate: cocoa solids, and cocoa butter. Cocoa butter is almost pure fat, and has little to no flavor, and is often sold as a beauty product. All of the flavor is in the solids, and the solids, once the butter is removed, is what is known as cocoa powder.
The cocoa powder can then be reconstituted with oil to produce bar chocolate. Cocoa powder is NOT a byproduct of the chocolate making process. If you discard the cocoa powder when you make chocolate, you do not have chocolate.
Whether the butter is left in or the powder is reconstituted with the butter depends on the specific manufacturer. Most manufacturers do use the cocoa butter to make the bar chocolate, and not some other oils (though they technically could).
The ratio of cocoa, oil, and sugar plus the precise roasting process are how you get the different kinds of chocolate.
Also note that cacao beans are roasted, like coffee beans, and so chocolate can have just as diverse a range of roasting flavors as coffee.
Bar chocolate is not used as often in making hot chocolate because the large amount of oil does not mix well. This can be mended with an emulsifier or by blending the drink.
Fox Music on June 12, 2015:
Thanks for sharing this delicious and informative hub "What is the Difference Between Hot Chocolate and Hot Cocoa?"
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 25, 2014:
I've discovered -- quite recently -- that some of it's much better than other brands. Even the same brand made by different people can make a tremendous difference. You should be able to make it less rich if you put more milk and less cream into the chocolate, but it's still very rich.
When I was growing up, it was the syrup, that doesn't really taste like either cocoa or chocolate to be honest with you.
Kate Swanson from Sydney on February 25, 2014:
Thanks for this excellent explanation! I've always been aware of three kinds of hot chocolate - syrup-based (yuk), powder-based and melted chocolate, but I hadn't thought about naming distinctions.
I grew up with the powder stuff. Perhaps because of that, I find 'real' hot chocolate too rich - as you say, it's like drinking a bar of chocolate and I find I can't manage more than a few sips.
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 16, 2014:
Me too, kerlund! I love it!
kerlund74 from Sweden on February 15, 2014:
Interesting:) My children acctually don't like hot chocolat... But I think it is the best!
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 13, 2014:
Thank you, Ron! You should definitely try Hot Chocolate. It's so different. For me the first time was like drinking a chocolate bar.
Ronald E Franklin from Mechanicsburg, PA on February 12, 2014:
Wow! I not only never knew the difference between hot cocoa and hot chocolate, I never knew there was a difference. And I've just realized that I've probably never tasted hot chocolate. Thanks for an informative hub. Voted up, interesting, and useful.
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 06, 2014:
Me too, Cynthianne!
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 06, 2014:
You're in for a real treat! Let me know how it turned out for you!
Thelma Alberts from Germany on February 05, 2014:
I have always thought hot cocoa is the same as hot chocolate. Thanks for the heads up. I´m gonna make my first homemade hot chocolate tonight before going to bed, based from your video tutorial. Voted up and useful.
Cynthianne Neighbors on February 05, 2014:
Great article! I love both hot cocoa and hot chocolate. :)
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on February 02, 2014:
I'm glad it helped you. Hot chocolate was an incredible and new experience for me. I hope you try it and love it!
Rose Clearfield from Milwaukee, Wisconsin on February 01, 2014:
I had no idea! Thanks for the detailed information.
Becki Rizzuti (author) from Indianapolis, Indiana on January 31, 2014:
Thank you Eddy! I'm glad I could help you out with your question. If you've never had hot chocolate, you should definitely try it!
Eiddwen from Wales on January 31, 2014:
Thank you so much for this great hub which has answered my question too. Voted up and looking forward to many more by you.