Skip to main content

Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Chicken Eggs

After becoming fed up with the lackluster flavor and subpar freshness of store-bought eggs, I decided to get some egg-layers of my own.

What is the difference between brown and white eggs? Yellow and orange yolks? How can you tell an egg is fresh, fertile, or free-range? These and many more answers await!

What is the difference between brown and white eggs? Yellow and orange yolks? How can you tell an egg is fresh, fertile, or free-range? These and many more answers await!

What's the Difference Between White and Brown Eggs?

There seems to be a lot of debate about which is better, white eggs or brown? Depending on where you are, you are likely to get all sorts of answers. The French, for instance, believe the darker brown an egg is, the better it tastes. They've even developed a breed, the Maran, that lays eggs that are a deep chocolate brown. So what is the difference between white and brown eggs?

It basically comes down to breed. Some chickens lay brown eggs, and some lay white eggs, but it goes deeper than that. Breeds that lay white eggs tend to be leaner breeds that handle extreme heat very well. Brown-egg layers tend to be very large, with thick feathering that makes them more suitable to extreme cold and more susceptible to heatstroke. Because of this, most eggs sold in the southern United States are white, and most of the eggs sold in the northern United States are brown.

A veritable rainbow of eggs!

A veritable rainbow of eggs!

Are There Other Colors of Eggs?

Yes! In fact, some breeds of chickens are even known for laying blue eggs. This might be because a few centuries ago, some chickens were bred with pheasants, who have colorful eggs. Hybrids like these are unusual but not impossible. As far as I know, no one is currently trying to make new lines of these hybrids.

Ameraucana, Arucauna, and Cream Legbars are three breeds known for blue eggs. When these birds are bred to brown-egg-laying chickens, the resulting hens will lay green eggs. These, along with the blues, can vary in tint and depth of color.

There is a bit of debate over the differences between these colored eggs. Some people feel they taste better; others think that they may have nutritional differences. I have yet to see any scientific studies.

Yellow vs. orange yolks

Yellow vs. orange yolks

Why Are Some Egg Yolks Orange?

The color of the egg yolk should be very bright yellow or deep orange. The difference in color is based on what the chicken is eating. Chickens who only eat the grain feed given to them will lay eggs that are yellow. Chickens that are free-range and eat mostly bugs and vegetation will produce these orange yolks. There may be nutritional differences, but I can't definitively tell you what they are.

Fertilized vs. unfertilized eggs

Fertilized vs. unfertilized eggs

What's the Difference Between Fertilized and Unfertilized Eggs?

Many people think that you need a rooster for a hen to lay eggs. This isn't so. In fact, most of the eggs you buy at the grocery store (unless otherwise labelled) are in fact unfertilized. If there's no reason for a commercial egg farmer to have roosters, so most don't bother.

Most of the hens producing eggs today have never seen a rooster in their life. However, I know some people buy their eggs from a farmer's market or directly from the farm. How can you tell if those are fertilized? It's really quite easy.

How Can You Tell if an Egg Is Fertilized?

Once you crack an egg open, look for a white spot on the yolk. If you can't see it use a spoon to roll the yolk around until you can. If the white spot looks like a dot, it is an unfertilized egg. If the white spot looks more like a doughnut or bull's eye, it is fertilized.

Why Would You Want Fertilized Eggs?

You may ask why you'd want a fertilized egg. The answer is pretty simple. People who raise chickens often prefer raising their own instead of buying new chicks every couple of years, so they keep a rooster around. However, every egg is not going to be wanted for hatching; instead, the extras are sold to be eaten.

In the meantime, the rooster will keep the hens happy and might even defend them from predators. Some people claim fertile eggs taste better. This appears to be a matter of opinion.

That's one big egg!

That's one big egg!

Why Are Some Eggs So Big?

In the stores, you can usually find small, medium, large, and jumbo or extra-large eggs. You might wonder why this is. Some may speculate this has to do with breed, but in the commercial industry, it usually has more to do with a hen's age.

The Older the Hen, the Bigger the Eggs.

The older the hen, the more likely she is to produce these larger eggs. In fact, some breeds, like the Rhode Island Red, are so notorious for this that once they start producing eggs too big for sale, they're slaughtered for meat. The largest chicken egg on record was over 7 ounces in weight! That's nearly half a pound!

Smaller Chickens Yield Smaller Eggs.

As far as backyard flocks go, some of the smaller eggs are indeed from bantams. Bantams are small breed chickens. They can lay just as many eggs as their larger counterparts, but they'll be considerably smaller. In fact, I have some Seramas, the smallest chicken breed in the world, and their eggs tend to be around 0.9oz in weight, as compared to a normal large store-bought egg, which is 3oz.

Bantam eggs usually have much more yolk than white in them and are just as edible. Many people prefer bantams simply due to their smaller space requirements.

So, how do you know if an egg is fresh?

So, how do you know if an egg is fresh?

How Can You Tell if an Egg Is Fresh?

It’s a bit disturbing to know that some eggs end up sitting on a shelf somewhere for up to six weeks before someone buys them. So how can you tell if an egg is fresh? It’s easy.

The Float Test

If you put an egg in a bowl of water, and it sinks to the bottom and lays on its side, then it is as fresh as you can get it. If it sinks but stands on its end, then it is still fresh enough to eat, but it is getting older. If it floats to the top of the water, it’s an old egg.

Sadly, most of the eggs I bought at the grocery store were this way. That’s why I invested in my own laying hens. I can profess the fresher the egg, the tastier it is!

Other Ways to Tell if an Egg Is Fresh

  • If the shell seems unusually thick, then it is fresh.
  • If the yolk stands really tall after you’ve cracked the egg, it is fresh.
  • If the yolk has wrinkles or dissolves into a puddle when you crack it open, then it is an old egg.

Can You Hatch Fertilized Eggs?

Yes and no. Although you will sometimes see fertilized eggs at your local health food store, they have been refrigerated and may also be old. Normally a hen will lay an egg every other day (or sometimes every day) until she feels she has enough eggs. At this point, she'll go broody—meaning she'll start to lay on the eggs instead of abandoning them as she's done in the past. Only then will the eggs start to develop, and after 21 days, all the chicks will hatch, despite being laid on different days.

The problem with this is that the older an egg is, the less likely it is to hatch once it's incubated. Most breeders don't use eggs past 10 days of age, although they can technically hatch as old as three weeks of age; there just won't be as many. Before being incubated, the eggs must not freeze or get too cold; this will kill them before they have a chance to start developing.

If you really want to hatch some eggs, you're much better off buying "hatching eggs" from your local farmer or breeder. These will be fresh and kept at room temperature until they are ready to be used.

How many eggs can one hen produce?

How many eggs can one hen produce?

How Many Eggs Does One Hen Produce?

This is a loaded question. Most of the breeds used in the commercial egg industry start laying eggs when they are 4–5 months old. These breeds tend to lay an egg every other day, sometimes an egg every day, but this doesn't last long.

When the hen reaches two years of age, her "peak productivity" will be lost, and unless she's someone's pet on a small farm, she'll likely be slaughtered for meat and replaced by a pullet (a hen under a year of age). If allowed to live, she'll still produce eggs, just not as many, until she becomes truly elderly, at which point she'll stop altogether, sometimes as young as three, sometimes as old as five or more.

Most hens generally live to be around five years old, although some have made it into their teens. Since no one is breeding specifically for longer-lived chickens, this seems to be the result of pure chance.

With all that being said, there are many breeds of chickens bred for all sorts of purposes. Some are ornamental and win shows for their beauty, others are raised purely for meat, while others may even be bred for cockfighting (which is illegal in most of the US—not to mention cruel). These breeds of chickens may only lay seasonally, or they may just produce eggs sporadically. Instead of having up to seven eggs a week, you'll likely end up with one or none.

© 2013 Theophanes Avery