The Original Fantasy Fudge Marshmallow Cream Recipe (Chocolate or Vanilla) - Delishably - Food and Drink
Updated date:

The Original Fantasy Fudge Marshmallow Cream Recipe (Chocolate or Vanilla)

I strive to provide family-tested favorite recipes, as well as smart and fun methods for solving everyday problems. Be smart; have fun!

Creamy vanilla or traditional chocolate fudge. Choose your favorite, or do like I do and make both!

Creamy vanilla or traditional chocolate fudge. Choose your favorite, or do like I do and make both!

For a while there, I thought I lost this recipe forever because Kraft stopped printing it on their marshmallow creme jars. But luckily, I've found the recipe, and I refuse to lose it again. I'm sharing it with you today and hope you find this delectable fudge as irresistible as I do.

Ingredients

  • 3 cups white sugar
  • 3/4 cup (1 and 1/2 sticks) real butter
  • 2/3 cup evaporated milk
  • One 12-ounce package semi-sweet chocolate chips or white chocolate chips
  • One 7-ounce jar marshmallow cream
  • 1 teaspoon real vanilla extract
  • 1 cup chopped walnuts, optional

Instructions

  1. Lightly coat the bottom of a 13x9-inch baking pan with cooking spray or butter; set aside.
  2. Over medium heat, combine sugar, butter, and evaporated milk in a 3-quart saucepan. Place a candy thermometer in the pan so that the bottom tip of the thermometer is well into the mixture but does not touch the bottom of the pan.
  3. Heat, stirring, until the butter has melted, and the sugar has dissolved. You'll know the sugar has dissolved when the mixture feels smooth rather than grainy as you stir.
  4. Continue cooking and stirring the mixture over medium heat, allowing it to reach a full, rolling boil. As you stir, drag the spoon across the bottom of the pan to prevent the mixture from scorching or burning.
  5. Stir constantly as the mixture boils until your candy thermometer reads 234°. If you don't have a candy thermometer, boil and stir the mixture for 5 minutes.
  6. Remove pan from heat. Add chocolate chips to hot mixture, and stir until melted.
  7. Stir in vanilla extract, marshmallow cream, and nuts (if desired) until evenly blended.
  8. Pour mixture into greased pan and allow to cool. Cut into squares; store fudge in an air-tight container for optimal freshness.

Note That Vanilla (White Chocolate) Chips Melt More Slowly

If you're using white chocolate chips instead of chocolate chips, you'll find the white chips don't melt as quickly. As the directions say, take the pan off the heat and stir the chips in to melt them as much as you can, but know that you will probably need to put the pan back on the heat in order for them to melt more completely. Even then, the chips are often stubborn and do not melt entirely. Stir to get the mixture as smooth as possible, and then remove from the heat once again, adding the vanilla and marshmallow cream thereafter.

Changes I've Made to the Recipe

I do have a few of my own preferences when making Fantasy Fudge.

  • Kraft's original recipe calls for margarine; I use only real butter.
  • The recipe also calls for semi-sweet chocolate chips; for the vanilla/white chocolate fudge, I substitute those for white chocolate chips.
  • Also, the recipe states that nuts are optional, but I never use them. My kids don't really like them, and I prefer the taste of pure chocolate without the distraction of nuts.

Other than that, this recipe is perfect, and I don't change a thing!

This Fudge Is Sure to Woo Everyone

I Almost Lost This Recipe!!

When I was growing up in the late '60s and '70s, my grandmother (or "Granny" as we called her) would make fudge every Christmas. The fudge was rich, creamy, dense, and delicious—and one of the highlights of the holiday. I looked forward to her Christmas visits. She was my grandmother, so of course, I wanted to see her and spend time with her, but I also wanted to get my paws on some of that fudge!

Years passed, and when my grandmother was no longer physically able to cook, I took over fudge-making duties. It was partially a tribute to my grandmother, and also because I didn't want to see this family tradition die. Eventually, I had children of my own, and I'm so glad they get to experience the excitement of the annual "fudge-making day" at our house. I use the Kraft Fantasy Fudge recipe—the same recipe my grandmother used. In addition to the traditional chocolate fudge she made ever year, I also make vanilla fudge—or I guess you could call it white chocolate fudge. It is my personal favorite.

In the past, Kraft printed the Fantasy Fudge recipe on their Jet-Puffed Marshmallow Creme jars (some call it "marshmallow fluff"), but one Christmas, I was surprised and slightly panicked to find that they had stopped including the recipe on the label. The new jars had a Fantasy Fudge recipe on it, but they had changed the ingredients, and it was absolutely not the same recipe! I had never saved a copy of my beloved fudge recipe, as I foolishly assumed Kraft would print it on their jars forever. Luckily, I was able to locate the original recipe and am sharing it here. I have no intention of ever losing this recipe again.

How to Properly Use and Clean a Candy Thermometer

Comments

Michelle Homewood on December 31, 2019:

Love all the different recipes. Am looking for old potato soup where it has chunks of potatoes, celery and onion. I can' remember if you use heavy cream with milk or not. If you know a recipe like this please let me know.

Thank you,

Michelle

Carla Jo on December 30, 2019:

Its still on the Kraft jar of marshmallow cream, i substitute 12 oz of skippy peanutbutter for the chips makes a excellent peanutbutter recipe

Mimi on December 11, 2019:

Should a hand mixer be used or stir with a spoon. Why is my fudge grainy at times?

Thank you

Laura on December 06, 2019:

I always use butter now

The original recipe I had shared to me used Parkay

Not available any longer

Colleen becker on November 09, 2019:

I did it just as said ,very nice soft fudge ,Very easy to make.

Lisa on June 01, 2019:

I made pumpkin, it was trial error at 1st. It was very good in the end. Try it you will like it better than chocolate or strawberry.

Debby on December 30, 2018:

I used this recipe in so many other times of fudge. Everytime I do everyone wants my recpice. I make peanut butter fudge, eggnog fudge, Pina colada fudge, peppermint fudge. So many other kinds. Thank God for Kraft marshmallow cream

Linda on December 13, 2018:

Try it with Reese's peanut butter chips - amazing peanut butter fudge to die for.

Debbie on December 11, 2018:

Can I use peanut butter chips for the same recipe

Linda Adair on December 05, 2018:

I just want to thank you for posting the original recipe. I went to the store to get the ingredients for the fantasy fudge, and like you said the recipe on the kraft . I bought what the recipe called for. However, I will be using your recipe. Again Thank you

Leslie on December 01, 2018:

Thank you, thank you, thank you! When I was first married I used to make this for my husband and then they stopped printing it on the bottle! I’ve never been able to make fudge well since. I am trying this today and then I will WRITE IT DOWN!

Kristen Howe from Northeast Ohio on December 17, 2015:

Great chocolate fudge recipe hub! I'll take both anytime. This looks delicious and easy to make as well. Yummy photos!

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on May 17, 2012:

Brakel12, it warms my heart to read your comment! Thank you so much! I'm so glad I was able to provide you with this meaningful recipe. I remember my own grandmother making it every Christmas and was dumbfounded and siappointed when Kraft quit printing the recipe on the MM Creme jars. Thank goodness for the internet! Enjoy your fudge and your grandkids, and thanks for stopping by!

Audrey Selig from Oklahoma City, Oklahoma on May 15, 2012:

My mother used to make this all the time in the 60s and on until she died. It was the original recipe. I wish I had kept her cookbook. When she died, I was distraught and hardly kept anything. Anyway, you are a lifesaver, as my grandkids love that recipe. Now I can make it the way she did. She also made peanut butter fudge. Thanks so much for bringing my past back to me. Happy writing.

Dale Hyde from Tropical Paradise on Planet X on March 26, 2012:

I was surprised! I got the email and it showed that many repins, lol. I have never had one snatched up like that! So the hub link with each repin (behind the picture..that can not be changed)and from those pins others probably will repin it. Like the Domino effect!

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on March 26, 2012:

No kidding?! Wow! Thanks so much for pinning it!

Dale Hyde from Tropical Paradise on Planet X on March 26, 2012:

That sounds wonderful SmartAndFun. I got a message that 20 people had already re-pinned this pin! Amazing!

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on March 25, 2012:

Thanks Dale! I am working on my getting my pinterest account going. I will find you when I do and share some of your cool stuff!

Dale Hyde from Tropical Paradise on Planet X on March 25, 2012:

What a delicious sounding treat! I will have to give this one a try for sure! I can almost smell the Fantasy Fudge, lol. I have had to pin this on Pintrest under my recipes there. :) Great hub! Voted up, interesting and useful.

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on February 19, 2012:

Thanks, Becky, both for stopping by and for sharing!

Becky Katz from Hereford, AZ on February 19, 2012:

I haven't made this fudge for several years because I could not find the recipe. THANK YOU!!! And thank you wheelinallover for sharing. I would not have found it if you hadn't. I shared also.

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on February 19, 2012:

Well aren't you the sweetest thing EVAH, Mr. Wheelinallover. Thanks for caring and tweeting! I promise that begging for views was not the intent of my forum post, LOL. If you were local I'd wip you up a big batch of fudge right now! For sure I'm gonna follow you, though. Thanks again!

Dennis Thorgesen from Beatrice, Nebraska U.S. on February 19, 2012:

Those on my social networks are in for a surprise. I personally could eat fudge until I explode. It is a good thing I believe in moderation. One of my good friends used to give me a batch of fudge for my birthday. I usually ate the last piece with Christmas dinner. Christmas is two and a half months after the gift was received.

I like your comment to moonlake. My fudge gifts were received when I lived alone so there was no one to share with. Voted up, interesting and SHARING this with my favorite twitter followers.

SmartAndFun (author) from Texas on January 01, 2012:

Well moonlake, you'll have to make some for yourself sometime! And if your family asks you to share, remind them that they don't like it! Thanks for commenting!

moonlake from America on January 01, 2012:

I didn't know the recipe wasn't on the jar anymore. I love this fudge but my family doesn't. They want Papa's Old Fashioned Fudge, so that is what he makes.