How to Make Healthy Homemade Peanut Butter Cups

Updated on July 19, 2016
Turtlewoman profile image

Kim is a board-certified holistic health coach, healthy living and cleanse consultant, and studied under Drs. Andrew Weil and Walter Willet.


Every year around Easter, I always buy popular chocolates like Cadbury's Cremes, cute rabbit shaped chocolate bars, and Reese's peanut butter cups. Although I don’t really celebrate the holiday, I still find myself participating by indulging in chocolate candies.

Now that I’ve learned how easy and healthy it is to make my own chocolate candy, there’s no turning back. As much as I still love the original Reese's Candy, I enjoy making healthy replicates of junk food.

I will show you how easy it is to make chocolate using only the healthiest ingredients on earth. The best thing about homemade candy is that you know exactly what goes into the candy.

I used to stock up on these during Easter. Now that I've learned how to make my own Reese's Pieces candy, I definitely don't miss the unhealthy ingredients!
I used to stock up on these during Easter. Now that I've learned how to make my own Reese's Pieces candy, I definitely don't miss the unhealthy ingredients! | Source
Trader Joe's Reese's has nothing on my homemade ones.
Trader Joe's Reese's has nothing on my homemade ones. | Source

Chocolate and peanut butter are like one of the best combinations in the world of desserts. When you substitute for dark chocolate you get to eat guilt-free knowing that you are putting antioxidants in your body.

What about the sugar? This recipe includes half a teaspoon of Stevia, which is a natural sweetener from the Stevia plant.

What about preservatives? None! That’s one of the benefits of making your own chocolate at home!

Is it complicated? No, it shouldn’t even be called a recipe because it doesn’t require any cooking skills. You just mix the ingredients together and pop it in the freezer.

I used to eat a lot of candy bars, especially almond joy and peanut butter cups. Now I just make a huge batch and keep it stocked in my refrigerator. The funny thing is, the commercially made candies don’t even appeal to me anymore.

What's the Special Ingredient?

The secret ingredient, one that is underrated, is raw cacao powder.

I’m sure you’ve heard about the health benefits of chocolate, but do you have any idea how healthy it really is? I’m not talking about the commercially made milk chocolate. I’m not even talking about dark chocolate, which by the way does have health benefits.

Cacao has more antioxidants than any other super food tested, far exceeding red wine, blueberries, green tea, and Rooibos tea. Its ORAC value is 4x higher than green tea! Originating from South Africa, this super food is raw, vegan, organic, and gluten free.

All chocolate originates from the cacao (cocoa) bean. Cacao beans that are unprocessed are rich in nutrients. Let me introduce you to the closest source of cacao bean, cacao powder.

Cacao powder is basically the cacao bean that has the fat (cacao butter) removed. As you see in this recipe, cacao powder can be used to create chocolate by mixing it with a sweetener and healthy oil.

4.5 stars from 11 ratings of Reeses Candy


The original recipe was adapted from Kimmi Harris.

Please note that my recipe uses the healthiest possible ingredients, in terms of antioxidant levels. If you alter it by using a different ingredient, your candy will still taste great- minus a portion of the health benefits. Since it has raw cacao powder, it tastes more bitter. If you are not used to the taste, feel free to use cocoa powder. And if you're feeling lazy, just melt a chocolate bar for the bottom layer.

While I appreciate the originality of her recipe, I still like to alter it to the way I like it. The author used melted unsweetened chocolate pieces combined with honey. I used raw cacao to make the chocolate base. The more antioxidants, the better! I actually prefer cacao's deeper and slightly more bitter flavor.

For the sweetener, I only used a tiny bit of Stevia, a natural sweetener. You have an option of swapping it with honey or agave.

Bottom Chocolate Layer:

  • 2 tbsp melted coconut oil
  • 2 tbsp peanut butter (smooth)
  • 1/4 cup cacao powder (or unprocessed cocoa powder)
  • 2 tsp stevia (or honey)

Top Peanut Butter Layer

  • 2 Tbsp melted coconut oil
  • 4 Tbsp smooth peanut butter
  • 1 tsp stevia

Optional: 1/4 tsp of vanilla extract in each layer.



  1. Melt coconut oil, and honey in a sauce pan or double boiler. Add the cocoa powder and peanut butter and stir until all the ingredients are combined.
  2. Use a spoon to pour chocolate mixture into mini muffin cups with liner. Put in freezer for 10 minutes. **You can also use the mini silicone baking cups. I just think the cupcake liner looks closer to the original Reese's Peanut Butter cup.
  3. In the meantime, heat the top layer mixture in the microwave and mix.
  4. Remove the bottom chocolate layers from the freezer.
  5. Pour the peanut butter mixture over the chocolate layer. Place them back in the freezer for about 30 minutes, or until they're hard.
  6. Pour yourself a glass of milk and indulge in these peanut butter cups.

For the lazy version just melt your favorite chocolate bar over a saucepan and use that for the bottom layer.

Questions & Answers

    © 2012 Kim Lam


      0 of 8192 characters used
      Post Comment

      • JanisaChatte profile image

        Janisa 4 weeks ago from Earth

        These sound so healthy! I'm a bit scared too make them as I'm so used to the traditional Reese cups, but I'll give it a try, maybe using sweeter chocolate and peanut butter to start :D

      • profile image

        rosana 14 months ago

        Hello, would you know how many calories in one of these delicious cups?

      • CapCooL profile image

        Edwin B Lowry 2 years ago from PA

        Very nice hub, it made me hungry for some of these.

      • Kristen Howe profile image

        Kristen Howe 2 years ago from Northeast Ohio

        Kim, I haven't had Reese's peanut butter cups in a long time. Voted up for useful, since it's healthy for you. Congrats on Editor's choice.

      • profile image

        Linda 4 years ago

        I made these and they were really good, but I tried using Stevia in both layers and ended up also adding the honey because they were not sweet enough. Maybe it's just me!

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 5 years ago from California

        Sounds great! What a thoughtful gift. Happy birthday to your Dad...and thanks for stopping by Celeste!

      • celeste inscribed profile image

        Celeste Wilson 5 years ago

        Oh my father is going to loooooove me. He is a dark chocolate and peanut fan. I am most certainly going to pin this and make it for his birthday. Thank you so much. Gift for Dad, done and dusted.

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 5 years ago from California

        My apologies Barbara, add cocoa powder and peanut butter.( not salt) and that is for the bottom layer.

      • profile image

        Barbara 5 years ago

        Ummmm, the Easy Instructions say, "add cocoa powder and salt..." The ingredients list shows no salt. How much salt? Is the ingredient list correct for the bottom letter to use peanut butter? I thought that would be top layer only. Did I read something wrong?

      • SJBossalini profile image

        SJBossalini 5 years ago

        Oh. My. Gosh.

        Thank you soooo much

      • billybuc profile image

        Bill Holland 5 years ago from Olympia, WA

        I am dead tired of all these recipes this month for the contest but I saw yours and knew it would be a favorite candy....your recipe...this needs to win in the contest. Great job!

      • carter06 profile image

        Mary 5 years ago from Cronulla NSW

        Oh wow thanks so much for this delicious recipe...have wanted to find out how to make theses for ages...and what a cool desert truck...wish it would come my way:) cheers

      • Just Ask Susan profile image

        Susan Zutautas 5 years ago from Ontario, Canada

        Can't wait to make these.

      • RTalloni profile image

        RTalloni 5 years ago from the short journey

        Oh me, these look fabulous. I'm in trouble now.

      • Victoria Lynn profile image

        Victoria Lynn 5 years ago from Arkansas, USA

        Yum! I didn't see this one before. Sounds delish with all those wonderful ingredients. Saving this recipe for sure. Many votes and sharing. Great job!

      • kittythedreamer profile image

        Nicole Canfield 5 years ago from the Ether

        This is freaking me out a bit because I was literally just thinking yesterday, "I wonder if there's a way to make not-so-fattening peanut butter cups!" Love this...thanks for sharing!

      • emilybee profile image

        emilybee 5 years ago

        These look great and good for us, too!!! Wow I will have to make these :-)

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 5 years ago from California

        Hi Jim, they are indeed healthy as long as you don't substitute any of the ingredients. Dark chocolate has a high amount of antioxidants and coconut oil has amazing healing properties. Coconut oil melts easily in warmer temp so I actually keep mine in the fridge. Maybe if you use less oil and more peanut butter, they'll stay firm longer. They should last for weeks, although they're usually eaten up pretty quickly lol. Enjoy! Thanks for stopping by!

      • jimcrowthers profile image

        jimcrowthers 5 years ago from Port Charlotte

        These look delicious, and they're "healthy"? Awesome!

        Do these need to be refridgerated, or do they stay firm at room temperature? I suppose, since they're made from coconut oil, they keep about just as long as Reeses?

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 5 years ago from California

        Thanks lord....enjoy!

      • Lord De Cross profile image

        Joseph De Cross 5 years ago

        I missed this one. Chocolate is a favorite treat. Reeses homemade with all the instructions needed wow! Voted up!

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 5 years ago from California

        Oh Billy, why are you apologizing? Just send me some Reeses after you're done making them. ;-) This is my favorite candy too and I haven't touched a 'store-bought' one since I discovered the health benefits of coconut oil. Thanks fo stopping by...have a wonderful weekend!

      • billybuc profile image

        Bill Holland 5 years ago from Olympia, WA

        I have been terrible about reading your hubs lately and for that I'm sorry. I saw this one and had to read it because that's my favorite candy. I will be trying this recipe and thank you for a well-written hub written just for me. :)


      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 6 years ago from California

        Thanks frogpetals, for stopping by. You can now enjoy candy without any guilt! I actually love the flavor of cacao. Let me know how they turn out! :-)

      • frogpetals profile image

        frogpetals 6 years ago from Christiansburg, VA

        These sounds wonderful!!!!!! Love the healthy aspect of it and the fact that it is cacao makes it even better!! Can't wait to make these!! Thanks!!!!

      • Turtlewoman profile image

        Kim Lam 6 years ago from California

        Thanks vellur and Vespa- I'm glad you're a fan of cacao powder as well!

      • Vellur profile image

        Nithya Venkat 6 years ago from Dubai

        I love this. Easy to make, delicious and nutritious. The photos look delicious and yummy. Thank you for this great, healthy and chocolaty recipe. Voted up and shared.

      • vespawoolf profile image

        vespawoolf 6 years ago from Peru, South America

        Another creative recipe! I love your use of cacao powder and stevia. Very clever...voted up and awesome.

      • BWD316 profile image

        Brian Dooling 6 years ago from Connecticut

        These look amazing defiantly going to try! Great job voted up useful awesome and shared!