Skip to main content

Review of Krusteaz Cookie Mixes (Plus Variations and Tips)

My double chocolate chip cookies using a Krusteaz mix as a base. Easy to make in just 20 minutes!

My double chocolate chip cookies using a Krusteaz mix as a base. Easy to make in just 20 minutes!

Krusteaz Makes the Best Mixes

Looking for fast, easy homemade-tasting treats for your family? Don't always have the time? In a pinch, I have tried just about every product on the market. Simply put, I've concluded Krusteaz mixes are superior.

Why I Love Krusteaz Mixes

  • Fast: As a mom of five, cookies go fast in my house and I'm always looking for ones that can be ready to go in 20 minutes.
  • Tastes Like Scratch: These are by far the best-tasting of any store-made mix and much better than any store-bought cookie.
  • Cheaper Than Homemade: Better yet, these are often on sale at my local grocery store for under a dollar, which makes them cheaper than from-scratch, especially the chocolate chip mix.
  • Lots of Varieties: Especially recently, the brand has been coming out with more choices in different flavors like lemon sugar or raspberry bars, and the newest flavor, pumpkin pie bar mix.
  • Gluten-Free Choices: No one in my family is gluten-free, but lots of my friends and visitors are, so I love having a good-tasting dessert option that is fast. I always keep a Kruteaz gluten-free chocolate chip cookie mix or gluten-free double chocolate brownie in my cupboard.
Krusteaz makes many different mixes.

Krusteaz makes many different mixes.

Good taste and rich flavor but may spread out unless you add extra flour.

Good taste and rich flavor but may spread out unless you add extra flour.

Krusteaz Butter Vanilla Sugar Cookies & Snickerdoodle

Both the Butter Vanilla Sugar Cookies and the Snickerdoodle mixes are versions of sugar cookies. The Butter Vanilla has an icing that you can put on top and the Snickerdoodle has cinnamon sugar that you roll the cookies into before baking.

Both of them taste sweet and make great crispy drop cookies. Because they are both basic sugar cookie recipes, I often use these mixes for quick cut-out cookies or any other kind of sugar cookie I want to make.

Use These Mixes to Make These Special Cookies

  • Thumbprint cookies: Put the cookies a muffin tin and add a bit of jam in the middle.
  • Sprinkle cookies: Roll balls of the dough in sprinkles, put on a baking sheet, and press down a bit, then bake.
  • Cappuccino chocolate cookies: Add 1 TB instant coffee to the dough, bake and then frost with melted chocolate chips. Yum! This is my very favorite cookie to have with tea.
  • Cut-out cookies: If you want to make shaped or cut-out ones, you may want to add extra flour (1/2 to 1 cup) so the batter is firmer and they don't spread out as much when they bake. Be aware that any batter with eggs is likely to spread and puff up. If you really want crisp shapes, you need to use my shortbread recipe.

Tips for Using Mixes

One web review complained that the sugar cookies spread too much. That is true if you are trying cut-outs. However, there are some things that make any mix work better.

  • Margarine: Use margarine in the mix if you want a crispier taste.
  • Butter: Butter does taste better and it makes them softer.
  • Flour: If you want to make cut-outs, add 1/2 cup of flour to the mix, or even up to 1 cup if the mix still isn't very stiff.
  • Chilling the dough: Cookies will spread less if the dough is chilled first. I often cut the cookies out and chill them on the pan.
Nice rich peanut butter taste

Nice rich peanut butter taste

Krusteaz Double Peanut Butter Cookies

Truthfully, this is one of the best mixes on the market. In fact, I can't tell the difference between this and homemade. They have a wonderful deep peanut taste and are very crispy. The new version includes peanut butter chips, which my kids like a lot. This uses oil rather than butter or margarine, which makes them even cheaper to make.

The dough is stiff and makes it easy to make the traditional fork marks. These are so popular in my household that I've come up with lots of variations below. My husband devoured the peanut butter mini chocolate chip ones I made just this week.

Use This Mix to Make These Special Cookies

  • Peanut butter cup: Press dough into mini-muffin cups and put in a Reese's Peanut Butter Cup. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes.
  • Kiss peanut butter: Press dough into mini-muffin cups and put a kiss (regular or caramel) in. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes.
  • Peanut, peanut: Pile on the peanut flavor by adding 1 cup of Reese's chips and 1/2 cup of peanuts. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes.
  • Peanut butter chocolate chip: Mix 1 cup of regular or mini chocolate chips into the dough. Mound up on a baking sheet and bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes.
  • Peanut butter chocolate frosted: Mound dough on the baking sheet, and press down with your hand to flatten. When they come out of the oven, frost them using canned chocolate frosting or homemade gauche made by putting 1 cup of chocolate chips, 1 tablespoon of butter, and 1 tablespoon of milk in the microwave for 1 minute. Mix and add some powdered sugar if it is too liquid (some chocolates require powdered sugar, others don't). Frost when cool. Try not to eat too many before serving!
Gingersnaps or gingerbread

Gingersnaps or gingerbread

Krusteaz Gingerbread Cookies

I love making gingerbread men and houses at Christmas time and have always made my own recipe until I discovered this product. Not only is it easy to make, but this version also has just the right amount of spices for my kids. So now I just look for sales and don't worry about remembering to buy molasses. In fact, not having to buy all of the ingredients not only saves time, but also ends up being much cheaper, and I can make a small batch when friends come over.

Unlike the sugar cookie mix, this one is great for cutting out without adding extra flour. However, it helps to chill the dough for a while. You can also just make the dough up and keep it in the refrigerator for making some quick treats when guests come over unexpectedly during the holidays.

Use This Mix to Make These Special Cookies

  • Whoopie pies: Make the dough and shape it into a 2-inch diameter log (like refrigerated doughs you buy) and put in the refrigerator overnight. Slice into 1/4-inch circles. Bake in a 350-degree oven for 10 minutes. Cool. Put a dab of vanilla frosting on one and put another on top to make Whoopee pie. These are terrific snacks for parties.
  • Warm ice cream sandwiches: A food truck near our house makes these, and they are absolutely amazing. Make the cookies like whoopie pies and while they are still warm, put a scoop of ice cream in between and flatten. To make this work better, I actually scoop out ice cream first and put it on plastic cling wrap, and flatten it until about the size of the cookies. You could even use one of those hamburger presses. Put the flattened ice cream back in the freezer until you are ready to use them. Yum!
  • Gingersnaps: Use the same log and cut very thin slices. Put slices on a baking sheet covered with foil or parchment. Sprinkle sugar on top. Bake in a 350-degree oven for about 7–8 minutes or until lightly brown. These are great with coffee or tea.
  • Christmas gingerbread men: My signature Christmas treat is making gingerbread men and then frosting them with white frosting, red or green sprinkles, and then using red and green M&Ms for eyes and buttons. My kids prefer this with sugar cookies, but I'm partial to gingerbread.
  • Gingerbread: I had an extra box after I made all of my cookies last Christmas, so I saved it and used the recipe for making gingerbread. One of my favorite desserts is gingerbread with whipped cream on top!

Chocolate chips are not cheap, so this variety ends up being the best bargain in the Krusteaz line up. In comparison, refrigerated doughs have a funny taste to them, and so do Chips Ahoy. These are so quick to make, and they taste as good as my homemade recipe. I honestly can't really tell the difference, and my picky family can't either. So why not choose the cheapest, easiest, and fastest homemade treat?

Use my tips above to make the cookies crispier or softer. Or try my "accident" recipe below. I'd mistakenly heated my margarine one minute instead of 20 seconds and was in too much of a hurry to let it cool down. When it melted the chocolate chips in the mix, I added another cup. My family loved these. Yours might, too!

Cook Time

Prep timeCook timeReady inYields

10 min

10 min

20 min

36 (two-inch) cookies

Ingredients

  • 1 box Krusteaz Chocolate Chunk Cookie mix
  • 1 stick margarine, melted 1 minute
  • 1 egg
  • 1 cup chocolate chips

Instructions

  1. Melt the margarine in the microwave for 1 minute. It will be hot. Combine the margarinen with the Krusteaz mix and egg. Stir. The chocolate chips in the mix will melt.
  2. Cool for a couple of minutes.
  3. Add chocolate chips to the mixture and stir.
  4. Put spoonfuls of the mix on a baking sheet covered with parchment or foil.
  5. Bake at 350 degrees for 10 minutes or until done.
My double chocolate chunk cookies

My double chocolate chunk cookies

Questions & Answers

Question: I am using the Triple Chocolate Krusteaz mix and there is a recipe on the box for soft batch cookies. Am I to add the brownie mixture (water, oil & egg) as well as the butter, cream cheese and egg? I did that and it was very wet. I am baking it now - hopefully, it will turn out.

Answer: I have not done the soft batch recipe, but I suspect that you don't add both the water/oil/egg and the butter/cream cheese/egg. I think you probably need to choose one or the other. However, I've had many "mistakes" turn out to be rather tasty.

Question: Do you have recipes for partial boxes of cookie mix (large professional size)?

Answer: My suggestion is to measure out all of the box and then divide it into 2 or more portions and put that in a ziplock bag in the freezer. Then take what the instructions say and divide that also. You might want to look at the instructions to help you decide how to divide up the box. For example, it is hard to divide up an egg, so if the box says to make it with 6 eggs, I'd either divide the box by 6 or 3.

Question: Can I use the Krusteaz cookie mix in my cookie gun?

Answer: I have never used one of these mixes in a cookie gun. You possibly could use the sugar cookie mix but you might need to add a bit more butter, or else make sure the butter is very soft or melted when you mix it.

Question: Can I use Triple Chocolate Chunk cookie mix to make brownies?

Answer: If you mean you want to make these in a pan like brownies, that should work great. It will take a bit longer to cook them. If you want something that is more like brownies, you should add some cocoa powder.

Question: Can I use the cookie mix as the base for my lemon square recipe?

Answer: The Krusteaz Sugar Cookie base would work very well in a Lemon Squares cookie in my opinion. It is a soft sugar cookie.