Food Safety: Expiration Dates, Recalls, and Romaine Lettuce in the 21st Century


Linda explores food facts, folklore, and fabulous recipes, one ingredient at a time.

Fresh Produce

Fresh Produce

The Produce Problem

Do you re-wash your thrice-rinsed salad greens? I confess that I do. Every bit of produce that enters my kitchen receives a baptism before being subjected to the chopping board. Tomatoes, cucumbers, and even those “don’t-eat-the-skin fruits like squash and cantaloupe” are given a scrub and a rinse. Think about it. If the peel is “unsavory” and your knife blade pierces that skin to ultimately slice and dice the interior, haven’t you just moved bacteria from point A (skin) to point B (fleshy inside)?

You know that you need to exercise caution when handling raw meat. You’ve been warned that raw eggs should not be consumed by people who have fragile immune systems. And, raw cookie dough is suspect because of uncooked flour in the mix. Of course, there is an easy remedy; the bacteria on meat, eggs, and flour are rendered safe when subjected to heat. Unfortunately, many of the fruits and vegetables that we consume are not given the same trial by fire and, despite our best effort, this can lead to serious, sometimes fatal consequences. That is one of the reasons why produce is recalled in the United States.

For example, in November of 2018, the U.S. Center for Disease Control (CDC) issued a warning that all romaine lettuce in the United States was unfit to eat and should immediately be discarded. This warning came just two days before the Thanksgiving holiday. The warning was not only for heads of romaine but also for any hearts of romaine, romaine in salad wraps, salad mixes, and packages of precut lettuce that could potentially contain pieces of romaine lettuce. A similar warning was issued in November of 2019, once again notifying the public that a toxic strain of E. coli bacteria could be present on romaine lettuce from the Salinas, California, area.



What's Up With Romaine?

There are several basic classifications of lettuce—leaf lettuce, iceberg, Boston (or Bibb), loose-leaf (which includes red leaf), and romaine or Cos. Although most of us can grow lettuce in our home gardens, the majority of commercial production is from the Salinas Valley of California and Yuma, Arizona.

It’s been theorized that contaminated irrigation water is the culprit in the Salinas Valley; as a result, farmers are required to test agricultural water four times per year. However, the growing industry asserts that they already perform tests every month and they have taken even more aggressive measures. Setbacks from septic systems have been increased and the boundary between livestock and agricultural fields has been tripled. But the problem still exists. According to a report by the Washington Post, investigators are considering whether the structure of the romaine plant itself might be the problem, that the funnel-shaped head creates an environment that shelters and encourages the pathogen.

As reported by the Post:

The timing of the E.coli outbreaks is striking: They have often occurred late in the growing season for a given region, when crops are being rotated. That has drawn attention of experts who are searching for some common environmental explanation for the recurring outbreaks. Trevor Suslow, vice president of produce safety for the Produce Marketing Association, said the season for romaine lettuce ends in the fall in the Salinas Valley. That’s just weeks after neighboring fields are often prepped with manure or composting materials for spring crops. The possibility of E.coli drifting to the lettuce fields—through water or wind or other means—is an “absolute current focus right now to determine why these seasonal outbreaks have been happening.” Suslow said the weather can exacerbate problems with the contamination. “This is all happening at a time when water temperatures and humidity is high,” he said. “Those things are shown to favor survival and persistence of bacteria.”

You might be wondering, "If the only bad romaine is from the Salinas Valley, why does all romaine have to be thrown away?" The answer is simply that not all romaine lettuce is clearly labeled to show where it came from.

What Can We Do to Protect Ourselves?

There is no guaranteed, 100-percent method of protecting yourself and your family from foodborne contaminants, but there are several things you can do to reduce your risks:

  • As explained above, wash all produce before you use it. Even if you will be removing the peel/skin/outer shell, wash to reduce the chance of cross-contamination.
  • Use proper storage/refrigeration methods for all foods. A link to the USDA guidelines is here.
  • Never store cooked and uncooked foods in the same container. Likewise, never ever should raw meat be allowed to come into contact with other foods. This includes storing raw meat in its original packaging in the refrigerator. Packages can (and often do) leak, and raw meat juices will make you very ill!
  • You might be wondering about fruit and vegetable sprays and washes. Do they work? In a word "no." Their effectiveness varies from manufacturer to manufacturer and so reliability cannot be guaranteed. An Assistant Professor and Extension Specialist in Food Safety at North Carolina State University recently spoke with Ayn Monique Klahre of TheKitchn.com. Click here for his recommendations.

What About Those Produce Stickers?

Since 1990, a standardized system of coding fresh produce has been established by the International Federation for Produce Standards (IFPS), a global coalition of fruit and vegetable associations.

What do they mean? If you know how to crack the code, you can tell at a glance whether or not the product you are holding is organic and maybe (not always) if it has been genetically modified (more on that topic in a moment).

  • If there are only 4 digits, the produce was grown by “traditional” methods, with standard application methods of pesticides. For example, all traditionally grown bananas are coded 4011.
  • If there are 5 digits, and the first number is a 9, the food is organic. An organic banana will have the code 94011.
  • Genetically engineered or modified (GE or GMO) produce will begin with the number 8. This isn’t foolproof, however, because labeling is not mandatory.

What About Expiration Dates?

"Best Before" and “Use By” are perhaps the least understood phrases in the English language. What was formulated to provide an indicator of freshness sadly causes tens of thousands of pounds of good food to be needlessly discarded by the public.

And, guess what, the manufacturers don’t (and can’t) know for certain how long their products will remain safe to consume. There are just too many variables: how was the product stored in the warehouse, in transit to your grocery outlet, allowed to sit in the backroom storage in the grocery store? And how was it handled once placed in your cart? Did you whisk it home immediately or did it sit for several hours in the trunk of your car while you ran errands? Manufacturers can do little more than offer their best guess on when their product will taste its best and be at its peak. The phrases “use by, sell by and best used by” can best be explained in this way:

  • Use by is the absolute last date that a product can be guaranteed to be of the best quality. This is not a safety date.
  • Sell by is the date that retailers need to remove the product from their shelves, assuming that when purchased it will still be good and safe to eat for a week in your home.
  • Best if used by is the industry’s best guess of when the product will be of optimum quality. Chips might be stale after the “best” date but are certainly still edible and safe.

Eat By Date is a handy website that provides specifics on how long your favorite foods are safe to eat.



How You Store Your Food Is Important, Too


  • Whether you have a kitchen shelf or drawer set aside for food storage or are lucky enough to have a large walk-in pantry your storage area should be dry, dark, and cool (don't use a cupboard next to the oven). Optimum temperature range is 50 to 70 degrees F.
  • Ever since my house was invaded by ants (protein with your Frosted Flakes anyone?) I have been fanatical about storing all of the dry goods in our pantry in sealable packaging. Glassware, tins, and Tupperware (or any generic plastic container) are all good options.


  • Your refrigerator’s temperature should be between 34 and 40 degrees F.
  • Clean up spills as they happen.
  • Store all foods in air-tight containers.
  • To learn more about safe refrigeration of foods and how long they can be refrigerated, click on this link from the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service.


  • The temperature of your freezer should be set to 0 degrees F or below.
  • Follow your manufacturer's guidelines on the placement of foods. A well-stocked freezer will operate more efficiently but care should be taken to allow for proper air circulation (this is especially important in frost-free freezers).
  • There are some "pantry" items that should be stored in the freezer, primarily because they have a high-fat content and, even if kept cool and dry, can turn rancid. Flour, nuts, wheat germ, and seeds should be kept in the freezer in a well-sealed labeled container.
  • Don't freeze foods that are going bad. Your freezer is not a time machine that will turn the clock back to when that dish was at its best.
  • Label everything with name and date it was placed in the freezer.
  • Do you have more questions? Here is a fact sheet from the USDA.


This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.

© 2019 Linda Lum


Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 12, 2019:

Kari, I don't use a special spray or rinse for my lettuce, but in the fall/winter months I typically don't purchase lettuce at all. I can live quite happily by making salads with shredded carrots and zucchini.

Kari Poulsen from Ohio on December 12, 2019:

I learned something new from this article. I never knew about the sticker numbers, I will watch these from now on.

The reason for the increased e-coli in lettuce by the Washington Post is very plausible. Finally, what do you use to wash your lettuces and other produce with?

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 10, 2019:

Eric is your goal more flavor or to tenderize? And what cut of beef are you using? Do a Google search on dry-brining. It's the "in" thing.

Eric Dierker from Spring Valley, CA. U.S.A. on December 10, 2019:

Cool Linda -- shall do. I am still having trouble with that Kale. I wash it but still have to soak it. I wonder if my acv and olive oil is does lend itself to stuff, Knock on wood we are so healthy around here I wonder.

Blueberries, Strawberries and Blackberries along with Romaine last night.Maybe not enough fish. Today I have more beef set up. Pepper the main spice.

But I am thinking marinading. What say you?

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 10, 2019:

Manatita I am relieved to know that you are back to normal (for you, that is LOL). Food borne illnesses are horrible things. I've only had it twice and my life and hope to never go a third round.

I have written about things you should never order in a restaurant. Look for "Don't Eat That: 16 Things You Should Never Order When Dining Out."

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 10, 2019:

Audrey that is exactly what prompted me to write this. I would say get to know your local produce market. Find a trusted source or, if you can, grow your own.

manatita44 from london on December 10, 2019:

Well, my Sweet,

Perhaps you had me in mind when writing this, or probably not. As you know, my bug lasted over a week. Don't know where it came from but I do go to restaurants. Reading your Hub it can come from my fridge too, or from using things with sell-by dates. Quien Sabes?

Your spiritual brother is better now and did cancel that doctors date at the last minute. Peace.

Audrey Hunt from Pahrump NV on December 10, 2019:

Excellent information, especially for folks like me who get paranoid about food ingestion. What's with romaine lettuce? It seems like every year we hear of an outbreak of e coli. Ewwwww!

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 09, 2019:

Shauna, thank you for your kind words and encouragement. The number 8 won't always show up--using the coding isn't mandatory. So much for truth in advertising, right?

I don't anticipate any extra calories--not going to any celebrations and my food is as good (or mediocre) as always.

Shauna L Bowling from Central Florida on December 09, 2019:

This is valuable information, Linda. I had no idea why romaine lettuce had been recalled, but you explained it well in this article. And it makes sense.

I was aware of the 9 on product labels indicating organic, but did not know about the number 8. I will definitely keep my eyes out for that one!

Excellent article, Linda and your timing is perfect. We're in the cooking and baking season. Let's stay healthy enough to enjoy all the extra calories!

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 09, 2019:

Bill, I'm simply sitting here shaking my head. That isn't quite the message I was hoping to convey you silly goose. Have a great week my friend.

Bill Holland from Olympia, WA on December 09, 2019:

Whew! I'm happy to say I am safe from this health concern. If I don't eat veggies, I can't get sick from them. A simple truth! LOL Happy Monday my friend.

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 08, 2019:

Oh golly Flourish, as I read your comment I automatically tucked my feet underneath me, getting them up off of the floor. Roaches {{{shiver}}}. You are right about other people's levels of cleanliness. That's why I'm not too keen on church potlucks.

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 08, 2019:

Aw, Angel thanks so much. I try.

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 08, 2019:

Doris, I don't know why (believe me, I've looked) but the USDA does not recommend the use of a chlorine bleach rinse for cleaning produce. But I find it commonly references on survival websites.

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 08, 2019:

Eric, I don't wash my produce in hot or even warm water. You're cleaning off surface dirt, not sanitizing. Even when I know I've washed salad greens, I always give them another plunge into cold water before I toss them in the salad spinner. It makes them crisp up more.

FlourishAnyway from USA on December 08, 2019:

Your mention of an ant infestation made me recall a person I used to help with their animals when I volunteered a lot in indigent communities. This one lady had a horrible case of roaches that was so bad you’d go into her walk-in pantry, turn on the light and roaches would scatter everywhere. They’d even burrow under tightly closed jar lids and other containers. It’s one reason I am very reluctant to eat anything someone made in their own homes (e.g., a gift of cookies or homemade preserves). You just don’t know what kind of circumstances and habits people live by. Today I read an article warning people about the dangers of home canned goods, as they are frequently gifted at the holidays but can pose a nasty botulism risk if people don’t follow appropriate standards of sanitation or if they even alter ingredients. I think I’m going to go wash my hands right now lol.

Angel Guzman from Joliet, Illinois on December 08, 2019:

You are the Hubpages Queen of Food Linda. Great insightful and important read.

Doris James MizBejabbers from Beautiful South on December 08, 2019:

Great article on food use and storage, Linda. Thank you for clarifying this. It is such a pity about romaine lettuce, which is my favorite lettuce. It does make sense about the timing of the lettuce harvest with the fertilization of nearby fields with manure.

A few years ago, I mentioned to an elderly friend (now deceased) that I was using vegetable washes on fresh produce, and she said that she used a solution containing a small amount of bleach to soak her lettuce and other produce, especially grapes, in. She thought it would kill the E. coli and other bacteria on the lettuce, and also kill any fungi on grapes (grapes are notorious for fungi, you know). I wonder if it would make romaine safe. One place where I shop had a sign over the lettuce assuring customers that their romaine did not come from the Salinas Valley area. I think I'll solve the problem by growing my own romaine in season from now on. But then my husband uses chicken litter on his little garden. Oh well, can't win for losing.

Eric Dierker from Spring Valley, CA. U.S.A. on December 08, 2019:

Well this is wonderfully written. And for me to remember don't wash once wash thrice. Why not. I have this good clock in my kitchen. It has great big hands. And sometimes I get Gabe to watch it for me. Crazy but to really wash lettuce or lemons it takes less than a minute. Obviously the same for tomatoes and strawberries.

I do not like warming my fruits and vegetables so a water bath seems wrong.What say thee?

Linda Lum (author) from Washington State, USA on December 08, 2019:

Pamela, that's an excellent point and something that I should research and possibly ad to this article. Thanks so much!

Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on December 08, 2019:

Linda, these are great tips to make sure you use produce and store it correctly. I always wash produce as well.

I was told some where along the line to look at the UPC number used for charging you when checking out and when the number begins with a 0 it is grown in the US. I see a lot of 8's on produce also that begins with an 8 and that may be genetically modified, but I do not know. Maybe you can shed some light on this.

Hope you are having a good Sunday, Linda.

Related Articles