Easy DIY: How to Make Peanut Butter at Home - Delishably - Food and Drink
Updated date:

Easy DIY: How to Make Peanut Butter at Home

I love discovering and sharing simple recipes that you can make at home. They make for a healthier option than store-bought products.

Never made peanut butter at home before? Here's an easy guide!

Never made peanut butter at home before? Here's an easy guide!

I've been making peanut butter at home for quite a while now. It's incredibly easy and the end result is so delicious that you'll never turn to store-bought peanut butter ever again! So many peanut butter tutorials have cropped up online, but here's my version to guide you through making peanut butter, even if you've never made it before.

It's easy to make peanut butter at home, with all natural ingredients.

It's easy to make peanut butter at home, with all natural ingredients.

Reasons to Ditch Store-Bought Peanut Butter

After making my first batch of peanut butter, the taste of store-bought peanut pales by a million times in comparison. Homemade peanut butter tastes so rich, fresh, aromatic and just plain awesome! So that's reason #1 to make your own peanut butter at home: the rich, creamy, superior quality of homemade peanut butter.

You won't believe how many extra additives are found in store-bought peanut butter. All those nasty extra ingredients alone are a great incentive to stop buying store-bought peanut butter. Making peanut butter at home guarantees that you know exactly what contents are in it.

The additives found in commercial peanut butter products are actually harmful to health, as we shall look at below.

The Dangers of Harmful Ingredients in Peanut Butter

IngredientHealth Dangers

Corn Syrup

This contributes to fatty deposits in the liver, clogs arteries, causes type II diabetes, speeds up aging, and weakens the immune system.

Hydrogenated Vegetable Oils

Hydrogenated oils do not occur in nature. They cause serious degenerative diseases, autism, type II diabetes, and cancer.

Preservatives

Benzoates, nitrites, and sulphites are just some of the preservatives used in the food industry. Alleged dangers of preservatives include migraines, weakness, hyperactivity, and asthma.

How to Make Peanut Butter at Home

Trust me, even if you are a complete newbie to this, you can make peanut butter at home, and you'll be surprised how easy it is. Once you get started, you'll stay away from store-bought peanut butter forever. I know I did!

What You'll Need

  • 2 cups peanuts (hulled)
  • 2 tablespoons coconut oil/peanut oil
  • Natural sweetener to taste (honey, maple syrup, organic palm sugar, etc.)
  • Oven (for roasting)
  • Food processor or blender

Note: In this tutorial, we're going to begin with raw hulled peanuts, which saves us the task of hulling. But we still need to roast them in an oven. If you don't have an oven, you can simply buy roasted unsalted peanuts and work from there.

Raw, unroasted peanuts ready to be made into creamy peanut butter!

Raw, unroasted peanuts ready to be made into creamy peanut butter!

Instructions

Step 1: Roast away! First, we're going to roast our peanuts. Ignore this step if you're using roasted peanuts. Preheat your oven to 350°F. Now spread your peanuts on your baking tray and plop them into the oven and toast them for only 10 minutes. Be very careful that you don't burn your peanuts, as this will affect the taste of your peanut butter!

Step 2: Skin away! Now allow your peanuts to cool and begin the process of removing their skins. Some peanuts may have already shrugged out of their skins due to the oven heat. For the rest, simply grab some peanuts and rub them between your palms. With this method, separate all the peanuts from their skins, or at least majority of them!

The process of roasting peanuts before blending them up.

The process of roasting peanuts before blending them up.

Step 3: Grind away! Now the fun begins! It's time to pour your peanuts into your food processor or blender (I used my trusty ol' blender) and begin grinding. In roughly the first 30 seconds, your peanuts will reach a gritty powdery consistency as shown below. Continue blending and it will slowly start oozing out some of the natural oils within the peanuts. Use a spatula or soup spoon to scrape down the sides. Don't lose hope just yet! In a few more minutes, the peanuts will start forming a mass as shown below.

Grinding up the peanut butter is quite a process but takes no more than a few minutes!

Grinding up the peanut butter is quite a process but takes no more than a few minutes!

Step 4: Make it spreadable! Once you reach this stage, you're pretty much done. All you need to do is to bring this peanut butter into a spreadable consistency. Take off the blender lid and add in 2 tablespoons of your preferred oil. I love coconut oil, so I used that.

Step 5: Add final touches. Once that's done, this is the stage where you add your natural sweetener (e.g. honey or maple syrup) to taste. I used shaved organic palm sugar.

Add in as much sweetener as you desire. Here I'm using organic palm sugar.

Add in as much sweetener as you desire. Here I'm using organic palm sugar.

Step 6: That's it! Would you believe it? Your peanut butter is all done now! Wasn't that easy? Store your peanut butter in an airtight glass jar in a cool place. I usually make 2 cups of peanut butter, and it always gets finished in three days max! It's that good.

Wow! Look at that yummy spoonful of peanut butter! Yes, I licked it up right after I took that photo!

Wow! Look at that yummy spoonful of peanut butter! Yes, I licked it up right after I took that photo!

Have Fun With Your Healthy Peanut Butter

The possibilities are endless! You can make so many flavors and variations with peanut butter. You can add raw cocoa powder for a healthy chocolatey version; you can also add Nutella, an amazing variation! Or you can even add chopped dried fruits like dates, figs, and raisins and skip the sweetener. Just be creative and you'll be surprised what you come up with.

There's a great load of healthy snacks you can enjoy with peanut butter. I don't mind enjoying a spoonful of plain peanut butter every now and then. The best quick-fix snack I usually have is peanut butter with apples. Enjoy and stay healthy!

Peanut butter and apples?! My favorite healthy snack!

Peanut butter and apples?! My favorite healthy snack!

Comments

Jessica on January 09, 2019:

Thank you, I will make my peanut butter at home. You are a blessing

siewmei on July 01, 2016:

Hi, any recommendation for a nice and decent blender?

Kristen Howe from Northeast Ohio on April 02, 2015:

What a great idea. I would love to try this, when I have a blender. Voted up!

Shannonrb on January 17, 2015:

I'm a serious peanut butter lover. I'm looking forward to trying this!

Alyeska Martinez on December 02, 2014:

This is so cool! I have always wanted to make my own nut butters. Great hub!

peachy from Home Sweet Home on October 26, 2014:

i had just roasted 200g peanuts but it doesn't taste like peanut butter coz I didn't put in the oil and sugar. Can I use 3 tbsp sugar and 2 tbsp sunflower oil?

cheeluarv from INDIA on May 06, 2014:

Thanks for sharing this wonderful recipe for peanut butter. In our country peanut butter was not sold till recent years.Now too, we could get them only in big supermarkets. Once I had a friend from US whose kid was very firm in having peanut butter sandwiches. So I tried my best to please him with peanut ,sugar and butter without the recipe.(Compliment was O.K not as smooth as he used have) Now I am happy to know the real recipe.

Preston and Kate from the Midwest on May 06, 2014:

Great! Thanks for the info. Next month maybe I'll get industrious and try the homemade peanut butter.

healthmunsta (author) on May 05, 2014:

Thanks, everyone!

@prestonandkate: Yes, I'm sure homemade peanut butter would freeze well on the sandwiches. I've frozen peanut butter before and it thawed wonderfully and there wasn't any big difference in the taste!

@thefedorows: I'll have to work out how much it cost me, since I don't remember how much I bought my bag of peanuts or my organic palm sugar for! I'm planning on making another batch soon, so when I go shopping, I'll take note of the prices and add that info into the hub! It lasts outside the refrigerator for up to 2 months. In the refrigerator, it can last from 3 - 6 months.

thefedorows from the Midwest on May 05, 2014:

This looks like a great recipe! Pinning to try sometime...when I get a food processor! Just out of curiosity, about how much would you say it costs to make homemade PB? How long does it last?

Preston and Kate from the Midwest on May 05, 2014:

Usually about once a month, I freeze homemade peanut butter sandwiches for my kids. I freeze them because I make homemade wheat bread, and homemade bread doesn't last long. Do you think this homemade peanut butter would freeze well on the sandwiches?

RTalloni on May 05, 2014:

Homemade has to be best, hands down. I hadn't thought of using coconut oil this way, but thanks much!

Rebecca Mealey from Northeastern Georgia, USA on May 05, 2014:

It's a great idea, making your own peanut butter and eliminating those harmful ingredients. And this is a great recipe for it. Thanks!