Athlyn loves "all things bread" and shares her tips and recipes for homemade bread, quick breads, and all varieties in between.
When even the dog won't eat 'em, you know that your dumplings have somehow morphed into awful, heavy dough lumps instead of the wonderful, steamed bread morsels they should be.
Some cooks find, to their alarm, that no matter how carefully they prepare them, their dumplings morph into heavy "hockey pucks." No amount of sticking to the recipe, tweaking the heat settings, or obediently "not peeking" seems to make a difference. Dumpling making should be an easy undertaking but it can be one that is fraught with difficulty.
The Secret to Fluffy Dumplings
There seem to be a whole set of "rules" about how to make dumplings, and in my experience, none of them are relevant to producing fluffy and tender dumplings. I make light dumplings all the time. I'm not overly careful about measurement and I lift the lid and peek because when they get near to the end of cooking time, I like to cut a slit in one and stick my finger inside to make sure the middles aren't raw.
Why Are My Dumplings Hard and Doughy?
So what do I do that is so different and critical to making wonderful tender dumplings? It involves one ingredient and is something I learned while dining with a friend who produced fabulous dumplings. She taught me what she did that made the difference. Once a person gets this right, making dumplings is easy.
The trick for making light and tender dumplings is to always use soft margarine or butter, simply replacing the lard portion with either of these. When you do, you will produce a light dumpling dough that puffs up as it's supposed to.
Traditional dumpling recipes call for lard or shortening. While these fats may be suitable for biscuits, they are not the best choice for dumplings. This is the make-or-break factor. And this was my grandmother's Waterloo. She faithfully stuck to using either lard or shortening, never suspecting that the fat was the culprit.
How Do You Know When Dumplings Are Done?
As I've mentioned previously, I cut a slit in one and peak to make sure the middles aren't raw. If the middle is significantly darker than the outside, the dumpling is not done!
I also make sure my heat is on the low side because I've found that when you put a lid on a pot, ingredients heat up and tend to stick to the bottom and burn. Many claim that ingredients have to be boiling in order to steam dumplings; this is not the case.
Dumplings take just minutes to throw together and they truly are the perfect accompaniment for soups and stews and they help to round out a meal. They have an unmistakable flavor that goes so well in savory broths.
Ingredients for the Best Dumplings
- 2 cups flour
- 4 teaspoons bakng powder
- 1/2 to 1 teaspoon salt, to taste
- 4 tablespoons soft butter or margarine
- 1 cup milk
How to Make Fluffy Dumplings
- Combine flour, baking powder, and salt in a bowl.
- Cut in butter or soft margarine that's been kept at room temperature. Use either a pastry cutter, a tablespoon, or your fingers to mix it into the flour mixture.
- Stir milk lightly with a wooden spoon and adjust the liquid amount to make sure that you have a moist dumpling dough.
- Drop by teaspoonfuls into a gently simmering pot and cover with a lid.
- Check after about 10–15 minutes by making a slit in a dumpling and looking inside to ensure that no raw dough is hiding in the middle. Continue checking until dumplings are cooked to your preference.
A Close Second to Biscuit Dough
You'll notice when looking at the ingredients that this is basic biscuit dough. It is, but as touched on, when making dumplings to achieve the difference in texture you have to use the right type of fat. You may also opt to add just a little more liquid so that your dough is on the moist side. Unlike biscuits that are baked in the oven, dumplings are steamed and cooked in hot liquid, so they cook in a different fashion and have a different taste and consistency.
Did You Know?
Dumplings are like drop biscuits, except they are steamed in a pot instead of baked in the oven.
Steamed dumplings should have a fluffy inner consistency and a velvety outside texture. Here are some tips to help achieve that.
- Make sure your soup or stew is on a gentle simmer. The liquid does not have to be boiling to cook tender dumplings. Remember that pot temperature rises once you put the lid on and you don't want the contents to stick to the bottom of the pot and burn.
- Drop dumpling dough into the liquid by teaspoonfuls. There's no need to worry about shaping perfect dumplings because they will puff up as they cook. Cover your pot with a lid so that the dumplings can steam and cook in the middle.
- Check your dumplings after about 10 minutes. The old rule of thumb was "no peeking" but this makes no difference to the finished result. Use a knife to cut a slit in a dumpling and check inside. Cook until dumplings are no longer raw in the middle. They should be slightly moist and light. Just as bad as undercooking is overcooking. Do not overcook your dumplings. They may disintegrate if left to cook too long.
Like a little sweet with your meat? Get creative and combine salty and sweet flavors.
Add the following ingredients to the above recipe:
- 1/2 cup of raisins
- 1 teaspoon chopped onion
- 1 tablespoon chopped pecans
Sweet Drop Dumplings
For a spicy, sweet flavor, add:
- 1/4 cup of raisins
- 1/4 cup of apples
- dash of cinnamon
Sweet Dumplings for Chicken or Turkey Dishes
Add peaches or mangoes to your recipe:
- 1/4 cup of raisins
- 1/4 cup of chopped peaches or mangoes
Best Dumplings Ever
You are now set to make light and tender dumplings every time. A few simple ingredients and a little know-how are all it takes to produce excellent results. Happy eating and please leave your comments if you've enjoyed these tips or try this recipe.
Questions & Answers
Question: Can you use self-rising flour for dumplings?
Answer: Yes, this might be worth a shot to cut down on prep time.
Question: My dumplings turned out too thick. What do I add to make them juicier without losing seasoning?
Answer: Depending on the meat you started with and your broth base, you could try adding either chicken or beef broth, so that you don't lose the flavorful taste.
© 2013 Athlyn Green
How Do Your Dumplings Turn Out?
Ranee on August 23, 2020:
This recipe was so easy and informative. The dumplings were perfect! And so delicious.
Carole on April 21, 2020:
Made and my best dumplings ever very pleased
Mar on April 02, 2020:
These were the best dumplings I have ever had. They turned out absolutely perfect, my partner thought the same.
Lamaina on February 04, 2020:
You did not say how much of each ingredient at start of your show you just had stuff in a bowel amounts???
Cher on September 24, 2019:
Amazing! I had NEVER made dumplings before and wasn’t sure what to expect! These were light, airy and beautiful with my chicken stew/soup! I will make this recipe for always now! Thank you!
Lala on August 19, 2019:
They fell apart a bit but they were so velvety and perfectly cooked. I’ve been making chicken and dumplings about every two weeks for the last 6 months and this is the best dumplings I’ve had. Yummy!’
Larbev on August 10, 2019:
Absolutely perfect dumplings!!! I've been making dumplings for 45 years and have always had different levels of disappointment, until now. Both my husband and I were pleasantly surprised with the "secret ingredient". Perfect, perfect, perfect!
KAY MYERS on April 22, 2019:
BEEN TRYING TO FIND THE PERFECT DUMPLlNG RECIPE F0R 60 YEARS...THESE TURNED OUT GREAT THE FIRST TIME. MY HUSBAND TOLD ME TO NEVER MAKE THE ROLLED-OUT KIND AGAIN. GUESS I'M NOT TOO OLD (79) TO LEARN A NEW TRICK!!
James on December 26, 2018:
Your secret is alot of baking powder and maybe the butter too. Boom. Delish.
Athlyn Green (author) from West Kootenays on November 11, 2017:
Thank you, Carol. Glad to hear they turned out.
Carol on November 11, 2017:
Best dumplings ever!!!!!
Earlyne on August 30, 2017:
I love dumplings with stew but 9 times out of 10 they turn out like hockey pucks. Thanks so much for the above recipe. I will definitely make them by following directions. Making dumplings sweet or savoury is a great idea too. Gotta try it!
amisyandre on March 23, 2013:
The secret to a good dumpling is the texture of the filling. The filling should be firm, consistent and springy.
Too many homemade dumplings suffer from fillings that are separate and grainy, and which do not offer sufficient resistance to the teeth.
moonlake from America on March 02, 2013:
They sound very good. Voted up.
Karen A Szklany from New England on February 19, 2013:
yuuuummmy! Can't wait to try to make these dumplings. Love the variations that you included, too.
Lots of "up" votes to this hub!