Skip to main content

Pittsburgh-Style Sandwich Recipe

Claudia has been writing recipes online for many years. She enjoys coming up with unique and tasty dishes, especially sweet treats.

Pittsburgh Style Sandwich...Yum!

Pittsburgh Style Sandwich...Yum!

What is a Pittsburgh-Style Sandwich?

It is easy to recognize a Pittsburgh-style sandwich. The french fries and coleslaw are the ingredients that make it so unique. Originating in a famous city eatery, locals and out-of-towners alike, have been enjoying this treat since the 1930s.

If you have ever been to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania or anywhere else around the area, chances are pretty high that you have seen a Pittsburgh-style sandwich on a restaurant menu. You may have even eaten one.

With the exception of finer restaurants and fast-food chains, practically every dining establishment in the western part of Pennsylvania serves its own version of this regional favorite. If the menu says Pittsburgh style, then you know it is going to have fries and coleslaw on it.

Originally made famous by the Primanti Bros. restaurant, it's always a top seller anywhere.

If you haven't been lucky enough to try one, you've probably seen the sandwich featured on various television food programs.

Give it a try! A Pittsburgh-style sandwich may not be the easiest sandwich to eat, but it's worth it.

Start your Pittsburgh-Style Sandwich With your Favorite Fillings

This is just a list of suggestions. If you don't eat meat, try an all-vegetable version or, if you love meat, try making one with a few different meats.

Cold cutsOther optionsCheesesCondiments

Turkey

Tuna salad

American

Mustard

Roast Beef

Egg salad

Cheddar

Mayonnaise

Pastrami

Chicken salad

Provolone

Ketchup

Corned Beef

Sausage

Swiss

Oil

Salami

Chicken breast

Colby-Jack

Vinegar

Ham

Sliced steak

Muenster

Horseradish

Capicola

 

Pepper Jack

 

Bologna

 

 

 

Ingredients for One Sandwich

  • 2 thick slices Italian bread
  • Approximately 1/8 pound deli meat (I used pastrami because to me, it is the greatest cold cut ever.)
  • 2 thick slices tomato
  • 2 slices cheese (I always use provolone for this sandwich. It adds a mildly sharp flavor to it and holds up well when taking big bites.)
  • Approximately 1/3 cup coleslaw (If you need a quick and easy recipe that is just right, try the one below. It only takes about 5 minutes to make.)
  • A big handful of French fries (Restaurants use those good greasy french fries, but at home, I don't have a fryer, so I use a bag of frozen potatoes. Bake them according to the directions on the package. I prefer thinner french fries, but crinkle-cut work well too.)
  • Condiments, if desired

Notes on Bread

Don't use a skimpy loaf of bread or thin slices for this sandwich. If you can find it, a nice hearty Italian bread is perfect. I have seen Italian bread around the entire Eastern part of the U.S., but I'm not so sure about other areas of the country. Look for it in your local bakery or grocery store. If you can't find Italian bread, any other hearty white bread will do.

Instructions

  1. Lay one slice of bread down on a plate.
  2. Put the meat of your choice on the bread (I use about 1/8 of a pound). For this sandwich, I used pastrami, because to me, it is the greatest cold cut ever.
  3. If you want, you can warm up the deli meat. Just heat a non-stick pan up and warm the slices for a few minutes. It does not take long. I enjoy a warm sandwich because it melts the cheese a bit.
  4. Place about two slices of your favorite cheese on top of the meat. As I said before, I warm the pastrami, so when I put the cheese on, it begins to melt. I always use provolone for this sandwich. It adds a mildly sharp flavor to it and holds up well when taking big bites.
  5. The next thing that gets added to the sandwich is French fries. Restaurants use those good greasy french fries, but at home, I don't have a fryer, so I use a bag of frozen potatoes. Bake them according to the directions on the package. I prefer thinner french fries, but crinkle-cut work well too. About one handful is enough for one sandwich.
  6. Place about 1/3 of a cup of coleslaw on top of the french fries.
  7. Finally, top off the sandwich with the second slice of bread. Gently press down so all of the ingredients mingle together.
The foundation for this sandwich is the bread.

The foundation for this sandwich is the bread.

A fresh loaf of italian bread is a great beginning to this sandwich.

A fresh loaf of italian bread is a great beginning to this sandwich.

Place the meat on the bread.

Place the meat on the bread.

Meat and cheese ready for the sandwich.

Meat and cheese ready for the sandwich.

Scroll to Continue

Read More From Delishably

Lay the cheese on top of the meat.

Lay the cheese on top of the meat.

Cheese is an important part of this Pittsburgh-style sandwich.

Cheese is an important part of this Pittsburgh-style sandwich.

French fries get piled on top of the meat and cheese.

French fries get piled on top of the meat and cheese.

Pile those fries high!

Pile those fries high!

Slaw piled high!

Slaw piled high!

Crisp coleslaw adds a fresh touch to the sandwich.

Crisp coleslaw adds a fresh touch to the sandwich.

Oil and Vinegar Coleslaw Recipe

Ingredients

  • 1 (16 ounce bag) of shredded coleslaw mix or shredded cabbage
  • 1/4 cup apple cider vinegar
  • 2 tablespoons sugar
  • 2 tablespoons canola oil
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • Pepper to taste

Instructions

  1. Whisk the dressing ingredients together in a large bowl and add the shredded cabbage.
  2. Toss until coated.
  3. Refrigerate at least 30 minutes before serving.
Fresh tomatoes

Fresh tomatoes

Fresh tomatoes, ready for the sandwich.

Fresh tomatoes, ready for the sandwich.

Tomatoes Are Great to Add

In the summer or any other time of the year, nothing beats a fresh beefsteak tomato that has just been picked and sliced. If you can't have one of those, then another tomato will do. Nice slices, about 1/4 inch thick, go on top of the coleslaw.

Enjoy your sandwich

Now it's time to enjoy this culinary delight! If you want, add a condiment to the sandwich. I love mustard, so I usually put on a generous portion.

You really don't need a side with this sandwich because it comes ready-made with french fries and coleslaw. Just serve with an ice-cold beverage and enjoy. A crisp dill pickle also hits the spot. Don't forget to have lots of napkins, and maybe even a fork and knife, because it does get messy!

Now if you'll excuse me, I'm going to have my lunch. Yum!

Primanti Bros.

Primanti Bros. is a Pittsburgh landmark that has been around since 1933. They originally sold sandwiches to truckers and the warehouse workers in the city's strip district. Over the years there have been some changes to the menu and the restaurant and, in recent years, they have expanded throughout the area.

A delicious Pittsburgh style sandwich.

A delicious Pittsburgh style sandwich.

© 2013 Claudia Mitchell

Related Articles